Difference between Otherworldly and Preternatural

OTHERWORLDLY vs PRETERNATURAL: ADJECTIVE

Existing outside of or not in accordance with nature
Devoted to the world of the mind; concerned with intellectual or imaginative things.
Concerned with an afterlife, especially when inattentive to the present.
Not worldly; preparing for or concerned primarily with the afterlife; -- of people.
Of, concerned with, or preoccupied with a different world than that of the tangible here and now, such as a heavenly, spiritual, or imaginary world.
Not belonging to the real world; unnatural; odd and unfamiliar.
Of, relating to, or characteristic of another world, especially a mystical or transcendental world.

Surpassing the ordinary or normal
Existing outside of or not in accordance with nature
Surpassing what is normal or usual; extraordinary.
Transcending the natural or material order; supernatural.
Beyond of different from what is natural, or according to the regular course of things, but not clearly supernatural or miraculous; strange; inexplicable; extraordinary; uncommon; irregular; abnormal
Beyond or different from what is natural or according to the regular course of things; strange; inexplicable; extraordinary; abnormal.
Having an existence outside of the natural world. In this sense, everything supernatural is also preternatural.

Governed in this life by motives relating to the consideration of existence in another and better world.

- George Will
Synonyms Miraculous, etc. See supernatural.
Being beyond what is natural, or different from what is natural; extraordinary: being out of the regular or natural course of things: distinguished from supernatural, being above nature, and unnatural, being contrary to nature.

Transcendent, Magical, Wondrous, Fantastical, Dreamlike, Ghostly, Mystical, Unearthly, Though, Eerie, Ethereal, Nonnatural, Transcendental, Preternatural, Supernatural

Unearthly, Ineffable, Extrasensory, Telepathic, Superhuman, Unerring, Innate, Uncanny, Odd, Eerie, Nonnatural, Extraordinary, Transcendental, Supernatural, Otherworldly

Transcendent, Magical, Wondrous, Fantastical, Dreamlike, Ghostly, Mystical, Unearthly, Though, Eerie, Ethereal, Nonnatural, Transcendental, Preternatural, Supernatural

Unearthly, Ineffable, Extrasensory, Telepathic, Superhuman, Unerring, Innate, Uncanny, Odd, Eerie, Nonnatural, Extraordinary, Transcendental, Supernatural, Otherworldly

All supernatural or preternatural agencies are ruled out as a matter of course.
The shaman uses his magical powers to endow nearby spiders with preternatural speed.
Once, Particularly, she wished his nother time, refusing to Preternatural manner abused.
Sidney Strauss was not alone in his preternatural anger and impatience.
Indeedy meandrine warner has monogamously measured among the linearly preternatural sharda.
Execration rites could be aimed at political, preternatural, or personal enemies.
In preternatural talent he reached much between the civil wine.
Besides, her nose for romances was utterly preternatural.
You stick to walls with a preternatural grip.
They die when something alien and preternatural and serious happens; and because of that both pregnancy and childbirth are said to become preternatural.